PIED3's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Defiance City Ep. 2]

Great pacing

This is really nice, the story seems well thought out and complex enough to be intriguing yet still simple enough to follow. The voice acting is great as are the sound effects. The animation isn't the most amazing thing but it does the job and some parts are really nice. The humour is subtle and proffesional (i especially liked the candles burning out when he made the lame excuse). All in all this seems like a great project and i look forwards to episode three!

[blue birdy's highs & lows]

A-may-zing

This is perfect. It goes with the music so well and i love your new style of coloring, looks a lot more detailed than your previous work. The multiple birds keeps it interesting and it's all in all very trippy and cool. Nice stuff!

TheBoogley responds:

thanks, it was a hell of a difficult technique to produce and I'm really happy you enjoyed it :)

[Who Will Win the Moon]

Ha ha

Just the idea of "Who will win the moon" was hilarious and you pulled it off well. The art style was great and the animation was neat too. It all looked very stylish. I enjoyed the punchline and i thought it was short and snappy. Good luck!

[Power Rangers! Pink]

That was insane!

Great animation, ridiculously good detailing and coloring for a such a fast paced thing and sweet fight choreography. Not sure about power rangers but thats probably just me being biased because it's a kids show. Short but sweet, looking forward to the next ones!

[POP! an adventure]

Sweet

Crazy smooth animation. Minimal resizing aswell (other than intentional resizing :P) The story was a little weird but the excellent score really helped pull it all together. All in all good stuff, the animation particularly!

turtleco responds:

the musical score is my favorite part.

[Rip.]

Great

The animation was fine, the art style was great and i loved the colors! What did you do the backgrounds on cause they were awesome. The story was perhaps a little to abstract for me but it all had a great feel to it. Very atmospheric.

[SS - Channeling]

Not very impressive.

Animals are beings of higher consciousness? To be honest your ideas are so awful that at times i genuinely think your just trying to piss people off. It is very disconcerting to see you passing of these entirely mythical, philosophical and extremely debatable unproven theories as science. What of your odd conclusions on "channeling" are based on evidance? The only attempted science was talk of the Pineal Gland which, when further researched, proved extremely ambiguous and uncertain. Do you not think its ridiculous to say you have somehow mentally communicated with your cat because you repeated a process until he "rests his head on you" or something of the sort? Animals do that the whole time, ESPECIALLY family pets etc. How does that in anyone prove any mental communication? I find this whole series ridiculous unfounded and foolish, i recommend you rethink this before you go too far.
Message aside the animation is fairly basic keyframing, the character is not particulary interesting and the replay button doesn't work.
Hopefully this wasn't too negative to warrant ignoring.

RiverJordan responds:

No, animals are lower consciousness ;) I made that clear in the video haha.

[Construction Men (Scene1)]

Pretty sweet

Very stylistic and great scripting and voice acting. Ended kinda abruptly though, seems like the start of something bigger. As a concept it's great and you pulled it off well so i look forward to part 2!

[Pico Jones]

Epic

The art was awesome, shame about the quality. The story was a little hard to follow because for the first half i was just trying to work out who was who, you couldn't have whown them punting on their helmets at the start or something? The animation was top quality too though there were perhaps a few too many tweens, though it was more acceptable because they were in space :P Good stuff and i look forward to next year!

[Warriors of the Portal]

Awesome!

That was great! Shame the quality isn't perfect cause you had to put it in a swf but other than that this is just amazing. Really great music and good job on getting all the original voice actors! Cool idea having multiple endings as well. Awesome!